Type

National Gambling Impact Study Commission Report

In June 1999, the National Gambling Impact Study Commission concluded its two-year exploration into the social and economic impact of legalized gambling in the United States. In fulfillment of their responsibilities, the Commission submitted a detailed report of their findings to the President, Congress, Governors, and tribal leaders. Please read the contents of the report below.

Introduction

Table of Contents

Chapter 1 Overview – The expansion of legalized gambling; impact and controversy (a moving target), the role of government (no master plan); the lack of information (time for a pause).

Chapter 2 Gambling in the United States – Lotteries (growth of lotteries, types of lottery games, the contradictory role of state governments); convenience gambling and stand-alone electronic gambling devices (issues); casinos; riverboat casinos; Native American tribal gambling; pari-mutuel wagering (the horse-racing industry, the greyhound industry, jai alai, issues, egd’s and the pari-mutuel industry, simulcasting and account wagering); sports wagering (issues); internet.

Chapter 3 Gambling Regulation – Governments set the rules; gambling and the public interest; regulating gambling (the federal role); the state role (lotteries); The administrative structure of casinos and pari-mutuel gambling; sports wagering; convenience gambling and stand-alone electronic gambling devices; advertising (supporting a restriction of advertising, the foundation for the ban: the Federal Communications Act, is the ban an indirect gambling regulation?; This chapter looks at gambling in New Orleans; general guidelines; underage guidelines.

Chapter 4 Problem and Pathological Gambling – The research (risk factors for problem and pathological gambling); estimating the prevalence (the commission’s research findings); characteristics of pathological gamblers; under-age problem gambling; the costs of problem gamblers (the costs to problem and pathological gamblers, the costs to society); treating the problem (private sector efforts, casino questionnaire, non-profit and other efforts, government response); conclusion; recommendations.

Chapter 5 Internet Gambling – The emergence of internet gambling; types of internet gambling sites; candidates for prohibition (youth gambling, pathological gamblers, criminal use); state of the law: the applicability of 18 U.S.C. § 1084; regulation or prohibition (state efforts, Native American internet gambling); an enhanced federal role at state request (federal efforts); obstacles to regulation; recommendations.

Chapter 6 Native American Tribal Gambling – Growth of tribal gambling; tribal sovereignty and Indian gambling (federal policy: failure of the “trust responsibility” and alternative revenue source to Indian gambling, the move toward self-determination, review of regulations, state criticism if IGRA, mechanism for handling impasse between tribes and states, other mechanisms); local community impacts; economic development; employment laws and Indian tribal governments; other issues for consideration (taxation, exclusivity payments, off-reservation gambling); recommendations.

Chapter 7 Gambling’s Impacts on People and Places – Determining the impact of gambling; growth and employment (pari-mutuel, Native American tribal government gambling, other gambling industries); a careful look at economic benefits (crime, financial and credit issues, other economic impacts, local effects); the social impact of gambling (problem and pathological gambling, adolescent gambling, responding to adolescent gambling, suicide, divorce, homelessness, abuse and neglect, local effects); conclusion; recommendations.

Chapter 8 Future Research Recommendations

Appendix 1 Commission Member’s Statements

Appendix 2 Commission Members

Appendix 3 Acknowledgments

Appendix 4 National Gambling Impact Study Commission Act

Appendix 5 List of References

Appendix 6 Sources of Information and Resources on Gambling

Appendix 7 Glossary

Appendix 8 Catalog of Gambling Laws, Regulations, and Ordinances

CkirbyNational Gambling Impact Study Commission Report
read more

Casinos Will Lead to Net Job Loss in Ohio

In the fall of 2009, Ohio voters were faced with a referendum to allow casino gambling in the state. Prior to the election, the Public Policy Analysis Group at Hiram College studied the social and economic effects that this form of predatory gambling would bring to the state. These researchers discovered that there would be a net loss of area jobs in the new casino locations. This would be due to the significant loss of non-casino jobs in these areas. Further, the policy analysts characterized the industry’s claim of creating 34,000 new jobs as “misleading.”

Report on Ohio Gaming Initiative – Statewide Economic and Social Factors

CkirbyCasinos Will Lead to Net Job Loss in Ohio
read more

The Effects of Predatory Gambling in Maryland

This May 2011 report from the University of Maryland, Baltimore County studied how Maryland residents have been affected by the many forms of predatory gambling now available in the state including slots, the lottery, and horse racing. The most significant finding was that individuals in the 18 to 29 age group appear most at risk of developing gambling problems. In addition, researchers found that “being male, single, African-American or other races (primarily Hispanic) are associated with an increase in the odds of being at risk for problem/pathological gambling. Most problem/pathological gamblers travel 6 to 15 miles to gamble, typically spend over 6 hours gambling during a single session, and generally gamble with others not related to them.”

Gambling Prevalence in Maryland – A Baseline Analysis

CkirbyThe Effects of Predatory Gambling in Maryland
read more

Native American Tribes and Payday Lenders Partnering to Avoid Oversight

To help “broaden” their portfolio, some Native American tribes are now partnering with pay day lenders to allow such companies to circumvent state laws in nearly 20 states, according to a recent report by the Center for Public Integrity.

Well-intended people have been talking about alternate economic solutions for Native American tribes for more than twenty years. Yet there is no sense of urgency for these Native American tribes to change their predatory business partnerships and, as evidenced by their entrance into the payday lending arena, the situation is getting worse.

Fights over tribal payday lenders show challenges of financial reform

CkirbyNative American Tribes and Payday Lenders Partnering to Avoid Oversight
read more

Predatory Gambling Negatively Affects Families

A 2010 article from the Institute of Marriage and Family Canada details the evidence linking gambling addiction to negative socio-economic consequences for Canadian families as the government attempts to “chase after increasing revenue.”

Government Gambling and Broken Families: How Problem Gambling Affects Families

CkirbyPredatory Gambling Negatively Affects Families
read more

Why Far Fewer Bettors Pony Up on the Horses

This Las Vegas Sun article offers some insights as to why horse racing events are “going the way of Latin.”  It describes how horse racing revenue has declined 30 percent at Nevada casinos in the past decade even as other forms of gambling, after taking a hit in the recession, have increased over that period.

2011 Why Far Fewer Bettors Pony Up on the Horses

CkirbyWhy Far Fewer Bettors Pony Up on the Horses
read more

The Reverse Robin Hood Effect

Using data acquired from the Florida Lottery Commission, Florida scholars assessed what groups were benefiting from the lottery-funded Florida Bright Futures Scholarships and who were being harmed. Not surprisingly, the study reported that the “net benefits of the scholarships accrue disproportionately to counties with heavier concentrations of white, wealthy, and well-educated households.” The study concluded by stating: “If the Florida Bright Futures Scholarships are going to be made more equitable, the citizens who are harmed — the poor, the less-educated, and minorities, as well as citizens who care about fairness — need to get involved.”

The second study below uses survey data and finds similar results.

The Reverse Robin Hood Effect – The Distribution of Net Benefits From the Florida Bright Futures Scholarship

Some Futures Are Brighter than Others – The Net Benefits Received by Florida Bright Futures Scholarships

CkirbyThe Reverse Robin Hood Effect
read more

West Virginia Legislature Votes to Fund State’s Racinos

In March 2011, West Virginia’s State Legislature voted on a bill that will use $10 million from an existing lottery to fund the state’s racinos for 10 years. Del. Mitch Carmichael, of Jackson, called the bill “the most ‘ridiculous’ he’s seen in several years.”

“Why should we single out a particular industry, the gaming industry and the Greenbrier Hotel, to give them special $10 million giveaways from the people of West Virginia,” Carmichael asked. “I just think it sets the wrong priorities.”

West Virginia Legislature Votes to Fund Racinos with Public Money

LesWest Virginia Legislature Votes to Fund State’s Racinos
read more

Government-Run Gambling Bigger Than Organized Crime

Should our democratic institutions be competing with organized crime for revenue? Philadelphia Inquirer columnist Monica Yant Kinney discovers an important distinction between illegal underground gambling and government-sponsored predatory gambling: “Bookies don’t prey on gamblers. Bookies don’t solicit. Gamblers find them.”

This lies in stark contrast to state governments using taxpayer money to solicit our fellow citizens to play the lottery and providing tax incentives to allow casinos to come to town.

Pennsylvania Competing with Mob Bookies

CkirbyGovernment-Run Gambling Bigger Than Organized Crime
read more

Internet Sweepstakes: Coming to a Strip Mall Near You

Internet sweepstakes cafes are popping up all over the country. One of the highlights from the article below is a quote from someone making big money in the sweepstakes industry on his customer base: “Lower-income customers are coming in because they’re bad at math…It’s like the lottery. The lottery is a tax on people who are bad at math. They’re coming in to try and catch a big break.”

Strip-Mall Casinos Multiply Across Nation

CkirbyInternet Sweepstakes: Coming to a Strip Mall Near You
read more